문제
package.json에 어디서도 부르지 않는 script 4개가 있다.
- scan:security:fixture: FE-GATE-013은 이것 대신 check:security:fixtures를
돈다. supply-chain.test.ts는 "게이트에 없어야 한다"고 단언하는데 script는
남아 있다. 게이트 밖 script 검사는 check|verify|test|drill|review만 봐서
scan:을 놓쳤다.
- build:profile: 이름과 달리 generate-runtime-config.ts만 돈다.
- generate:contract-set: 참조 0건.
- build:app-only: vite build와 매니페스트만 만든다. build-frontend.ts의
계약 세트·런타임 설정·Service Worker 단계가 빠진 dist가 나온다. 참조는
product-index-entrypoints 테스트의 진입점 목록 하나다.
참조 확인(새 기준 298201f, docs/reviews 제외): package.json 정의와 위 두
테스트 말고는 config/ci/gates.json, 생성 workflow, scripts, docs 어디에도
없다. 아래 세 script가 부르던 파일(generate-runtime-config.ts,
generate-contract-set.ts, generate-build-manifest.ts)은 build-frontend.ts가
그대로 부른다.
고른 방법
- 네 script를 지우고 진입점 목록에서 build:app-only를 뺀다.
- VERIFICATION_SCRIPT에 scan을 더한다. 게이트가 닿지 않는 scan:* script는
ungated-scripts.json 항목 없이는 check:ci에서 실패한다. 지금 남은
scan:security는 build:release-candidate를 거쳐 게이트가 닿는다.
- docs/operations/ci-quality-gates.md의 접두어 목록에 scan:*을 더한다.
버린 대안
- build:app-only를 build:vite-only로 이름만 바꾸기: 남길 사용처를 찾지
못했다.
- 접두어 대신 "게이트 밖 모든 script는 예외 목록에": dev·storybook·
update:*까지 목록에 올라가 목록이 커진다(리뷰 대안 비교와 같다).
- check:feature-index 정리(리뷰 개선 (4)): 지우기와 이유 문구 고치기 중
하나를 고르는 일이라 이번에 하지 않았다.
위험·한계
- 개인 습관으로 이 script를 쓰던 사람은 build-frontend.ts나 node
scripts/...를 직접 불러야 한다.
- 게이트 명령은 바뀌지 않아 CI 계약 기준선은 그대로다.
검증
- RED: 새 테스트 "rejects a scan script that no gate reaches"가 실패
(expected [ …(2) ] to deep equally contain '…: scan:orphan'). 정규식만
넓히면 저장소 검사 "reaches every verification script …"가
scan:security:fixture 한 건으로 실패.
- GREEN: ungated-scripts·product-index-entrypoints·supply-chain·
ci-workflow-generation 4파일 457/457 통과. check:ci의 세 단계를 pnpm
없이 직접 실행: generate-artifact-schemas --check PASS,
check-ci-contract.ts PASS(27 gates), generate-ci-workflow --check PASS.
tsc(tsconfig.node, tsconfig.test), 바꾼 파일 eslint 통과.
Refs: docs/reviews/2026-11-01-maturity-review/12-guardrails-ci.md 12-05
FE-GATE-021..025 rebuilt from source and drilled that build, so the drilled
bytes were not the promoted release. production_gate now downloads the
promoted-release artifact, extracts it against immutable_build's digest and
runs each drill with --release-root; the CI contract rejects a rebuild.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
check-ci-contract only caught test files outside the gates; check:* scripts
such as check:request-fanout and check:remediation-ledger ran nowhere. The
new check reads config/ci/ungated-scripts.json; three checks are now wired
into FE-GATE-010 and FE-GATE-012 and the rest carry a reason.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The gate count and the reference-feature LOC table were hand-typed and
drifted from the code, so they are removed; the LOC table now names the
files and the command that measures them. .env.example pointed to
layers.md for runtime profiles, which never described them; it now points
to the README section that does. ci-quality-gates.md lists the three
things DOCUMENTATION_READY checks, so the gate name is not read as a
general documentation-accuracy guarantee. The route list (③) and the
README config location (④) were already fixed by 14-03 and 13-15.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
FE-GATE-019 ran before the release existed and passed by comparing the declared
headers with a copy of themselves. The fixture result is now UNVERIFIED, the
gate runs in the production stage after deployment, and the live probe
requests the entry script the served index.html names (D-14).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
dependency-cruiser 18 cannot parse TypeScript 7, so it cruised no module, passed,
and its report and the docs claimed it checked the layers. The import graph is
the only checker; .dependency-cruiser.json stays as its rule file (D-11).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Icon vendor, design-system deep import and realtime composition were regular
expressions beside graph rules, and the regex missed relative deep imports
inside presentation. They are graph rules with fixtures now, with the
components/ui facades and page-templates named. package-script-graph.ts stays;
the reason is recorded.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
No CI job ran any scale tier, and every tier past pr compares timings only on
the baseline CPU. The pr tier checks counts, bounds and growth shape; it now
includes S2 composition, since S0/S1 stay under the noise floor and let a
quadratic accumulation through. The ungated-test check reads tier paths.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Drills held constant true verdicts and read public/ placeholders, so they
passed with no build or with JS assets deleted. They now check the local dist,
mark boot, live traffic and provider steps UNVERIFIED (exit 3), and FE-GATE-016
is retired because it repeated FE-GATE-025's FE-RB-005 drill.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The signed review is per release candidate, so the merge gate could never pass.
FE-GATE-009 now checks only the record format; the checked-in records are
source-controlled evidence, not command output.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
tests/architecture, tests/release, tests/scripts, the top-level
tests/features files and the browser-soak contract now run in
test:coverage (FE-GATE-005); check:adapter-inventory joins FE-GATE-010
and the image resolve-signal type fixture joins FE-GATE-003 (baseline
updated). check:ci fails on a test file no gate command reaches unless
config/ci/ungated-tests.json gives a reason; only the tests/scale suite
is listed, pending 11-03. defineFeatureModule's id mismatch is tested.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The generator rendered only gateIds[0] for non-matrix jobs, so
immutable_build never ran FE-GATE-027 and the snapshot test pinned that.
Each owned gate now gets its own run step, check:ci rejects a workflow in
which any contract gate has no run step, and release admission refuses
APP_PROFILE != RELEASE_TARGET. Both variables are documented.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Gate/command/artifact counts and the gate-shape SHA-256 were code
constants, so any real removal or addition failed check:ci and removal
fixtures passed only in a relaxed mode. They now live in
config/ci/contract-baseline.json (owner, reason) with
update:ci-contract-baseline; update:registry-baseline wraps the existing
registry script. Removal fixtures re-baseline and run canonical check:ci
and check:registries; CI_CONTRACT_MODE, --reduced-removal-fixture and
check:registries:structure are gone. ci-quality-gates.md lists the
baselines a new project resets.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>