The signed review is per release candidate, so the merge gate could never pass. FE-GATE-009 now checks only the record format; the checked-in records are source-controlled evidence, not command output. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2.7 KiB
Manual accessibility review checklist
Automated axe checks do not establish WCAG conformance. A human reviewer must
review all ten route records in artifacts/tests/a11y-manual/ against one
release candidate and sign them. The required scope is derived from the route
registry: APP_HOME, EXAMPLES_PLATFORM, EXAMPLES_UI, EXAMPLES_STATES,
EXAMPLES_AUTH, NOT_FOUND, REFERENCE_RESOURCE_LIST,
REFERENCE_RESOURCE_DETAIL, REFERENCE_RESOURCE_FORM and
REFERENCE_RESOURCE_STATUS. Copy the template fields exactly; the gate rejects
blank identity/timestamp/signature fields, pending verdicts, mismatched release
IDs, or missing routes.
The signed review is the release gate FE-GATE-028 (review:a11y-manual), so
it is required once per release candidate, not on every merge. The merge gate
FE-GATE-009 runs review:a11y-manual -- --format-only: each record must keep
the fields below with pending, pass or not-applicable (<reason>) verdicts,
and a record marked reviewed must be complete.
This list is not maintained by hand: verify:documentation compares it against
the installed route registry and fails when a registered route is absent. It
said six routes while ten were registered, which put the platform overview and
the three reference-resource screens outside the declared manual review scope
without anyone deciding they should be.
Allowed item verdicts:
passnot-applicable (<specific reason>)
Required record:
Status: reviewed
Route ID: APP_HOME
Release ID: <immutable release ID>
Reviewer: <human reviewer identity>
Reviewed at: <RFC 3339 timestamp>
Signature: <reviewer identity or approved signature reference>
Attestation: accepted
M1 Keyboard: pass
M2 Visible focus: pass
M3 Route focus: pass
M4 Modal focus: not-applicable (no modal on this route)
M5 Error association: not-applicable (no form error on this route)
M6 Color signal: pass
M7 Reduced motion: pass
Screen reader: pass
Notes: <observations and linked defect IDs>
The reviewer must verify:
- M1: every action works without a pointing device
- M2: every focused element has a visible indicator
- M3: route transitions move focus to a deterministic target
- M4: modal focus is trapped and restored, when a modal exists
- M5: errors are programmatically associated with their controls, when present
- M6: state never relies on color alone
- M7: non-essential motion is suppressed with reduced-motion preference
- Screen reader: headings, live regions, errors, and actions are announced once
EXAMPLES_UI requires real M4 modal and M5 field-error review; those items must
not be marked not-applicable on that route. Passing automated evidence means
only that tested pages had no critical or serious axe findings under the
recorded Chromium, Firefox, and WebKit runs.