Refs: docs/reviews/2026-11-03-maturity-review/README.md 02-06 11-06 12-09 10-01 11-03~11-05 12-02 12-04 12-05 12-08 14-04 16-02 # Conflicts: # docs/manual/01-add-a-feature.md # docs/manual/02-decision-tables.md # docs/manual/reference/patterns.md
3.5 KiB
Manual accessibility review checklist
Automated axe checks do not establish WCAG conformance. A human reviewer must
review every route record in artifacts/tests/a11y-manual/ against one
release candidate and sign them. The required scope is the route registry
(ROUTE_REGISTRY in src/features/installed-feature-contracts.ts): one
record per route, named <ROUTE_ID>.md. Copy the template fields exactly; the
gate rejects blank identity/timestamp/signature fields, pending verdicts,
mismatched release IDs, or missing routes.
The signed review is the release gate FE-GATE-028 (review:a11y-manual), so
it is required once per release candidate, not on every merge. The merge gate
FE-GATE-009 runs review:a11y-manual -- --format-only: each record must keep
the fields below with pending, pass or not-applicable (<reason>) verdicts,
and a record marked reviewed must be complete.
This document keeps no route list. A list here once said six routes while ten
were registered, and keeping it current made every new feature edit this file.
Instead verify:documentation fails, naming the route ID, when a registered
route has no record file. A new route starts from a copy of a pending record
with its title and Route ID changed.
Allowed item verdicts:
passnot-applicable (<specific reason>)
Required record:
Status: reviewed
Route ID: APP_HOME
Release ID: <immutable release ID>
Reviewer: <human reviewer identity>
Reviewed at: <RFC 3339 timestamp>
Signature: <reviewer identity or approved signature reference>
Attestation: accepted
M1 Keyboard: pass
M2 Visible focus: pass
M3 Route focus: pass
M4 Modal focus: not-applicable (no modal on this route)
M5 Error association: not-applicable (no form error on this route)
M6 Color signal: pass
M7 Reduced motion: pass
Screen reader: pass
Notes: <observations and linked defect IDs>
The reviewer must verify:
- M1: every action works without a pointing device
- M2: every focused element has a visible indicator
- M3: route transitions move focus to a deterministic target
- M4: modal focus is trapped and restored, when a modal exists
- M5: errors are programmatically associated with their controls, when present
- M6: state never relies on color alone
- M7: non-essential motion is suppressed with reduced-motion preference
- Screen reader: headings, live regions, errors, and actions are announced once
EXAMPLES_UI requires real M4 modal and M5 field-error review; those items must
not be marked not-applicable on that route. Passing automated evidence means
only that tested pages had no critical or serious axe findings under the
recorded Chromium, Firefox, and WebKit runs.
What the automated run scans:
- Every registered route, after the route's own
h1is on screen, so the scan never lands on the app shell's loading surface (tests/e2e/accessibility.spec.ts). A public route'sh1must equal its catalog title. - Protected routes after the demo sign-in, never the sign-in prompt. A list
read answers an empty list in the frame its descriptor declares (inside the
Envelope for
responseEnvelope: "ENVELOPE_V1"), and the scan runs only once no alert box is on screen, so a list page is scanned in its empty state. A read of one resource (a detail page) has no generic answer: that route is scanned in its failure state and the run records ana11y-data-stateannotation. - The reference sample's list in its success, empty and error states, its detail, its form with submit errors and its status page, each after that state is on screen (tests/e2e/reference-form.spec.ts, removed with the sample).