1.5 KiB
1.5 KiB
Root Tree Decomposition Checklist
Source integrity
- The tree records the detailed document hash and project revision/snapshot.
- Every node has at least one source anchor.
- Source anchors actually contain the material implied by the title.
- Runtime-dependent claims name evidence or use
NEEDS_EVIDENCE.
Topic quality
- Topic is a coherent engineering problem space rather than a directory name.
- Two Topics do not merely split the same causal chain arbitrarily.
- A large Topic is split when its records no longer share useful relations/criteria.
Case
- There is a specific incident, experiment, failure, diagnosis, or verification sequence.
- The title can be understood without inventing a historical story.
- The conclusion is bounded by actual evidence.
Reference
- The rule is reusable beyond the originating incident.
- It is not the Case summary rewritten declaratively.
- Scope and exception can be stated from sources.
Open Question
- The answer is not already in the analysis.
- Known/unknown/next verification are separable.
- Candidate options are included only when sources really considered them.
Decision
- A project choice is explicitly recorded or user-supplied.
technology is presentis not being treated as rationale.NEEDS_DECISIONis used if the direction is only a recommendation.
Duplication
- No two nodes have the same primary purpose.
- Relations are used instead of copying one record's entire content into another.