9.2 KiB
9.2 KiB
CA Skeleton Frontend Operational Contract — Controller Verification
일자 / Date: 2026-07-18
범위 / Scope: 2개 project-note의 사전 검토 artifact
Verdict: COMPLETE
요청 언어 / User language: ko
Controller Recomputed Coverage
아래 값은 lane의 자기 보고를 신뢰하지 않고 controller가 디스크에서 다시 계산한 값이다. finding coverage는 보존된 사전 스냅샷과 backend benchmark를 기준으로 했고, 교정된 live target은 별도의 integrity gate로 확인했다. 재계산 결과는 N=2, M=2, R=2, P=2, T=8, G=8이다.
Gate 1 — Scope
$ printf '%s\n' raw/project-notes/ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract.md raw/project-notes/ca-skeleton-operational-contract.md | wc -l
2
$ ls raw/project-notes/ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract.md raw/project-notes/ca-skeleton-operational-contract.md >/dev/null && echo 'source paths: 2 present'
source paths: 2 present
| Metric | Observed | Pass condition | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| N (in-scope paths) | 2 | 두 source path가 존재 | PASS |
Gate 2 — Matrix
$ rg -c '^\| `raw/project-notes/[^`]+` \| READ_FULL \|' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review/evidence-matrix.md
2
$ rg -o 'raw/project-notes/[a-z0-9-]+\.md' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review/evidence-matrix.md | sort -u | wc -l
2
$ rg -o 'raw/project-notes/[a-z0-9-]+\.md' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review/evidence-matrix.md | sort | uniq -d | wc -l
0
| Metric | Observed | Pass condition | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| M (matrix rows) / R (read rows) | 2 / 2 | M==N, unique paths 2, duplicate 0 |
PASS |
Gate 3 — Finding
$ rg -c '^### L1-F[0-9]{2}:' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review/lanes/lane-01-target-review.md
8
$ rg -c '^### 4\.[12] ' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review-report.md
2
$ printf '%s\n' raw/official-docs/vite-build-tool-official.md raw/official-docs/react-ui-library-official.md raw/official-docs/tailwind-css-utility-first-official.md raw/official-docs/tanstack-query-server-state-official.md raw/official-docs/zod-runtime-schema-validation-official.md raw/official-docs/react-router-official.md | while IFS= read -r f; do rg -c '^## Claims Extracted' "$f"; done | awk '{sum += $1} END {print sum}'
6
$ rg -o '(VITE-C[0-9]+|REACT-UI-C[0-9]+|TAILWIND-UTIL-C[0-9]+|TSQ-C[0-9]+|ZOD-VALID-C[0-9]+|REACT-ROUTER-C[0-9]+)' raw/project-notes/ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract.md | sort -u | wc -l
13
$ rg -n '^\| `FE-D00[3-8]` ' raw/project-notes/ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract.md | rg -v '\[\[raw/official-docs/' | wc -l
0
$ rg -n 'UNSUPPORTED_DECISION|BROKEN_CLAIM_REFERENCE|MISSING_CLAIMS_EXTRACTED' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review | wc -l
0
| Metric | Observed | Pass condition | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| T (findings) / P (file subsections) | 8 / 2 | target 8 findings, benchmark reference-only, P==R |
PASS |
source-backed FE-D003~008 / official source Claims Extracted / unique Claim IDs |
6 / 6 / 13 | 각 decision row는 source와 actual Claim ID를 가진다 | PASS |
| source 없는 FE-D003~008 row | 0 | 6개 row 모두 official source로 traceable | PASS |
| traceability failure markers (current-run artifacts) | 0 | marker 없음 | PASS |
Gate 4 — Quote
$ rg -c '^\$ sed -n' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review/sed-proofs.md
16
$ rg -c '\[이미 기록된 16개 sed proof\]' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review-report.md
1
| Metric | Observed | Pass condition | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| V / P_quotes / C / D / U | 16 / 16 / 0 / 0 / 0 | 16 proof commands가 16개 quote와 일치 | PASS |
| G (verified findings) / T | 8 / 8 | G==T |
PASS |
Gate 5 — Adversarial
$ rg -c '^\| L1-F[0-9]{2} \|' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review/adversarial-review.md
8
$ rg 'KEEP —' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review/adversarial-review.md | wc -l
1
$ rg 'DOWNGRADE —' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review/adversarial-review.md | wc -l
7
$ rg 'REJECT' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review/adversarial-review.md | wc -l
0
| Metric | Observed | Pass condition | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| adversarial rows / T | 8 / 8 | 모든 finding ID가 한 행씩 존재 | PASS |
| KEEP / DOWNGRADE / REJECT | 1 / 7 / 0 | master §4-1과 일치 | PASS |
Gate 6 — Priority
$ rg -o 'L1-F[0-9]{2}' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review/priority-recommendations.md | sort -u | wc -l
8
$ comm -3 <(rg -o 'L1-F[0-9]{2}' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review/lanes/lane-01-target-review.md | sort -u) <(rg -o 'L1-F[0-9]{2}' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review/priority-recommendations.md | sort -u) | wc -l
0
| Metric | Observed | Pass condition | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| priority finding IDs / unmatched IDs | 8 / 0 | §5의 각 권고가 §4.1 finding에 매핑 | PASS |
Gate 7 — Link
$ for p in $(rg --no-filename -o 'docs/superpowers/specs/[A-Za-z0-9_./-]+\.md' docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review-report.md docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review-controller-verification.md | sort -u); do test -f "$p" || echo "$p"; done | wc -l
0
| Metric | Observed | Pass condition | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 존재하지 않는 report artifact link | 0 | 참조한 artifact path가 모두 존재 | PASS |
Gate 8 — Language
$ forbidden_pattern=$(sed -n '103p' AGENTS.md | sed -E 's/.*\((.*)\).*/\1/' | tr -d '`' | sed -E 's/, */|/g'); rg -n "$forbidden_pattern" docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review-report.md docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review-controller-verification.md | wc -l
0
| Metric | Observed | Pass condition | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 금지 마케팅 표현 hit | 0 | 본문 hit 없음 | PASS |
Gate 9 — Artifact
$ find docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review -type f | sort | wc -l
13
$ for f in docs/superpowers/specs/2026-07-18-ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract-review/{evidence-matrix.md,per-file-findings.md,priority-recommendations.md,sed-proofs.md,adversarial-review.md,diagram-review.md,lanes/lane-01-target-review.md,lanes/lane-02-benchmark-patterns.md,process/pre-review-source.md}; do test -s "$f" || echo "MISSING $f"; done | wc -l
0
| Metric | Observed | Pass condition | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| current-run auxiliary artifacts / empty required artifacts | 13 / 0 | matrix, lanes, proofs, priority, adversarial, diagram, snapshot 존재 | PASS |
Final Live Target Integrity
$ python3 .claude/hooks/wiki_structure_lint.py --file raw/project-notes/ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract.md
PASS raw/project-notes/ca-skeleton-frontend-operational-contract.md
$ python3 .claude/hooks/wiki_structure_lint.py --file raw/project-notes/ca-skeleton-operational-contract.md
PASS raw/project-notes/ca-skeleton-operational-contract.md
$ xmllint --noout raw/diagrams/ca-skeleton-frontend/architecture-overview-2026-07-18.drawio raw/diagrams/ca-skeleton-frontend/architecture-deployment-2026-07-18.drawio
exit 0
| Check | Observed | Result |
|---|---|---|
| FE-D unique / definitions / dangling | 25 / 25 / 0 | PASS |
| FE-OC unique / definitions / dangling | 26 / 26 / 0 | PASS |
| Registry / acceptance gate / runbook / NFR | 8 / 26 / 5 / 15 | PASS |
| FE-OC-002..025 primary owner | 각 ID exact-one, §2 owner와 일치 | PASS |
| §20 dependency slug | 27개 branch row의 선행 slug가 모두 §20 row에 존재 | PASS |
| Source Claim IDs | 13개가 각 source의 Claims Extracted row에 존재 |
PASS |
| Frontmatter / Parent / Cluster / Sources | 7 / 0(root 면제) / 1 / 1 | PASS |
| Diagram stale marker | 0 | PASS |
| Independent semantic re-audit | latest target SHA daa0941a8dde21e6, actionable finding 0 |
PASS |
Traceability Note
사전 스냅샷의 검토 근거는 line quote와 sed proof로 보존했다. 후속 live target에서는 source-backed FE-D003~FE-D008이 6개 official source의 Claims Extracted heading과 13개 actual Claim ID로 연결되어 있다. FE-D006의 port ownership/non-duplication처럼 외부 source가 직접 증명하지 않는 설계 부분은 project decision으로 라벨링하며, project-local/inference decision도 그 경계를 유지해야 한다. UNSUPPORTED_DECISION, BROKEN_CLAIM_REFERENCE, MISSING_CLAIMS_EXTRACTED marker는 current-run artifact에서 0건이었다. 구현 repository와 실행 artifact가 없으므로 프로젝트 준비도는 계속 NOT_READY다.