The owner decisions in section 8 were settled on 2026-11-12 and the
section 7 recommendations went into separate PRs. Readers of the
review need to know where each one landed and that one recommendation
was withdrawn.
Add a table from each 7.x item to its PR, withdraw protect-kernel-
defaults (CIS dropped it in v1.7 and its kernel.panic_on_oops=1 would
reboot this dual-boot desktop on any oops), and note that the API
server certificate is measured with openssl on the host instead of a
blackbox probe.
Risk: documentation only.
Verification: the PR numbers match the open and merged platform-core
PRs on 2026-11-12.
All SSD Local PVs share the root filesystem with the OS, container
images and build caches; review A12 and risk 2. Owner decision 3 asks
for a plan only.
Compare four options (shrink the Windows SSD, a new SSD, the HDD, do
nothing), recommend a new SSD and otherwise the Windows SSD, and give
the migration: mount the new filesystem at the same /srv/k3s/ssd path
so no PV changes, two rsync passes around a short stop, rollback. Note
the scripts whose root-SSD findmnt checks must change in the same PR.
Risk: documentation only; status 제안.
Verification: the PV sizes and paths come from the 2026-11-11 cluster
inventory; the findmnt checks were found with git grep.
The review found no procedure for losing the host, restoring the k3s
datastore or Gitea, upgrading k3s, or checking the platform after a
reboot, and the existing runbooks live outside version control.
Add five runbooks and a restart-window procedure in docs/runbooks:
after-reboot-checks (clock, k3s and certificates, node, pods in
dependency order, public paths, Prometheus, alerts, runner),
k3s-datastore-restore, gitea-restore (file-only vs full restore, with
the warning that a PITR of the shared database also rewinds Keycloak
and tech-log), k3s-upgrade (patch within a minor), host-rebuild (order
and the easy-to-miss parts: host name for PV node affinity, Tailscale
address in the DNS config, time sync before the first k3s start), and
k3s-restart-window (what to apply in the one restart window, with the
PriorityClasses first). The docs map gains runbooks/ and design/.
Each runbook starts with its preconditions and the commands that check
them; on 2026-11-12 the backups they need are not installed yet, and
they say so.
Risk: documentation only. Restores and the rebuild were not executed.
Verification: a fresh subagent with only these files ran every command
in after-reboot-checks on the desktop and walked the others read-only;
its findings (about 60, e.g. a READY check that missed 0/1 Running
pods, `stable` pointing to another minor, a missing pgAdmin directory,
time sync after the first k3s start) are fixed here. The revised
after-reboot commands were rerun on the desktop and match the text.
Every repository path the runbooks name exists on main or in the
named PR.
The previous commit took the tech-log pg_hba change out of this PR
because W1's CNPG backup work owns the same Cluster manifest. Update the
review so it no longer says the fix is in this PR: section 6.1 now gives
W1 the exact change (commit 1c4ef9a to cherry-pick), its render
invariants and the RED/GREEN and kubectl diff evidence, and the W1
overlap table lists it.
Verification: grep finds no remaining "fixed in this PR" claim for
pg_hba; git diff origin/main...HEAD lists only docs/ and Traefik paths.
The desktop k3s runs production and all CI on one node, and three
incidents this week came from that. Record where the configuration is
weak before the next one.
The review scores 16 axes from 0 to 5 against the k3s hardening guide,
the k3s CIS self-assessment, the NSA/CISA hardening guide and the
Kubernetes security checklist, lists the top ten risks, compares the
rendered repository with the live cluster, and summarizes kube-bench,
kube-linter, Polaris and kubescape runs. Items W1 is already fixing are
marked and not repeated. docs/README.md is the new docs map that the
docs-system convention asks for when a docs folder is added.
Risk: documentation only. Tool results were checked finding by finding;
21 kube-bench FAILs and several Polaris and kubescape items are false
positives and are reported as such.
Verification: every count and value in the review comes from read-only
commands run on 2026-11-11 (kubectl get/diff, configz, journal, lsblk,
openssl). The scanners ran with pinned digests and their images were
removed afterwards.