fix(scripts): 제거 드릴의 URL 잔여 검사가 남는 route와 page object를 가린다
frontend-quality-gates / merge / static checks (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / merge / tests (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / merge / browser tests (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / FE-GATE-014 / config-compatibility (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / FE-GATE-026 / lab-performance (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / FE-GATE-028 / manual-accessibility-review (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / FE-GATE-015 / immutable-release-candidate (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / external-vulnerability-provider (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / promote-verified-immutable-candidate (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / deploy-promoted-release (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / FE-GATE-019 / hosting-header (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / FE-GATE-021 / runbook-boot-config (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / FE-GATE-022 / runbook-chunk-mismatch (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / FE-GATE-023 / runbook-api-degradation (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / FE-GATE-024 / runbook-telemetry (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / FE-GATE-025 / runbook-release-rollback (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / FE-GATE-018 / field-web-vitals (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / FE-GATE-017 / diagram-review (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / main / self-tests and removal drills (pull_request) Canceled after 0s
frontend-quality-gates / external-provenance-provider (pull_request) Canceled after 0s

문제: 새 눈 리뷰(정적 읽기)가 앞 두 커밋에서 넷을 찾았다.
- 같은 context의 첫 기능은 context 경로(`/invoice`)를, 뒤 기능은 그 아래
  경로(`/invoice/line`)를 받는다. 첫 기능을 지우면 context가 남는데도
  형제 기능 spec의 `"/invoice/line"`이 잔여물로 잡혔다.
- 선택 정적 세그먼트(`/invoice/edit?`)는 접두어가 `/invoice/edit?`가 되어
  아무 URL도 맞지 않았다.
- `` `/invoice${query}` ``와 Playwright `testDir` 안의 page object
  (`tests/e2e/support/*.ts`)는 찾지 않았다.
- `src` 검색이 대소문자를 가리게 되면서, 한 단어 ID(`invoices`)의 옛
  부분 문자열 검색이 잡던 route ID 잔여(`route.INVOICES_LIST.title`)를
  놓쳤다.

고친 것: 드릴이 지우기 전에 지울 route 경로, 남는 route 경로(플랫폼 포함),
지울 route ID(넘겨받은 플랫폼 ID 제외)를 함께 넘긴다. URL 문자열은 맞는
접두어 중 가장 긴 것이 지운 route일 때만 센다(남는 route와 접두어가 같으면
세지 않는다). 접두어는 선택 세그먼트 앞에서 끊고, `${`도 이어짐으로 본다.
`playwright*.config.ts`의 `testDir` 안 파일 중 vitest 시험이 아닌 것도
본다. route ID는 `src` 본문에서 이름 단위로 찾는다.

버린 대안: react-router `matchRoutes`로 모든 문자열을 route 표에 맞추기.
드릴 lib가 앱 라우터에 묶이고, 고정 접두어 비교로 같은 판정을 낸다.

위험·한계: 지운 route와 남는 route의 고정 접두어가 같으면(`/invoice/:id`를
지우고 `/invoice`가 남음) `/invoice/7`을 세지 않는다. 조각으로 만든 URL은
여전히 못 찾는다.

검증(desktop): feature-residue·feature-removal-argument 19개 통과,
check:types·eslint rc=0(로그 /tmp/claude-gates/w2fe2-res4/). 변이 다섯
(남는 route 비교, 선택 세그먼트, `${`, testDir 파일, route ID 검색을 하나씩
끔)마다 해당 시험 하나가 실패했다(로그 /tmp/claude-gates/w2fe2-resmut/).

Refs: 0925 FOLLOW-UP 09-07, 1105/16-04
This commit is contained in:
DongHyeonka
2026-11-13 05:40:54 +09:00
parent b05bf19c05
commit 03744e19cf
3 changed files with 174 additions and 37 deletions
+86 -20
View File
@@ -40,12 +40,17 @@ import path from "node:path";
* a test title), and no text rule tells that from a reference.
* - 0925 FOLLOW-UP 09-07. A spec that opens the feature by its URL alone
* (`page.goto("/invoices")`) failed only in FE-GATE-008, after the drill
* passed. `routePaths` are the removed feature's route paths: a spec with a
* string that starts with one, up to its first parameter (`/invoices` of
* `/invoices/:id`) and followed by the string's end or `/`, `?`, `#`, is
* residue. A path that is `/` up to its first parameter is not searched.
* What is still not found: a spec that names only a one-word ID, or builds
* the URL from parts. 03's hand list removes the feature's specs.
* passed. `routes.paths` are the removed feature's route paths: a spec, or
* another file in a Playwright `testDir` that is not a vitest test (a page
* object), with a string that opens one is residue. A string opens a route
* when it starts with the route's fixed prefix (`/invoices` of
* `/invoices/:id` or `/invoices/edit?`) followed by the string's end, `/`,
* `?`, `#` or `${`, and no route left behind (`routes.remainingPaths`) has
* a longer prefix that fits it. A prefix that is `/` is not searched.
* `routes.ids`, the feature's route IDs, are searched in `src` text by the
* whole-name rule. What is still not found: a spec that names only a
* one-word ID, or builds the URL from parts. 03's hand list removes the
* feature's specs.
*
* The drill applies the same rule to a sample a project lists in
* scripts/lib/removable-template-features.ts.
@@ -77,25 +82,69 @@ async function filesUnder(directory: string): Promise<string[]> {
return nested.flat();
}
/** The part of a route path before its first parameter or wildcard, or null for `/`. */
/**
* The part of a route path before its first parameter, wildcard or optional
* segment (`/invoices` of `/invoices/:id` or `/invoices/edit?`), or null when
* that is `/`.
*/
function staticRoutePrefix(routePath: string): string | null {
const segments: string[] = [];
for (const segment of routePath.split("/").filter(Boolean)) {
if (segment.startsWith(":") || segment.includes("*")) break;
if (segment.startsWith(":") || segment.includes("*") || segment.endsWith("?")) break;
segments.push(segment);
}
return segments.length === 0 ? null : `/${segments.join("/")}`;
}
const prefixesOf = (routePaths: readonly string[]) =>
new Set(routePaths.map(staticRoutePrefix).filter((prefix): prefix is string => prefix !== null));
/** `/invoices`, `/invoices/7`, `/invoices?tab=1`, `/invoices#x`, `/invoices${query}` open `/invoices`. */
function opens(value: string, prefix: string): boolean {
if (!value.startsWith(prefix)) return false;
const rest = value.slice(prefix.length);
return rest === "" || /^[/?#]/u.test(rest) || rest.startsWith("${");
}
/** The Playwright `testDir`s the repository's `playwright*.config.ts` files name. */
async function browserTestDirectories(root: string): Promise<string[]> {
const configs = (await readdir(root).catch(() => [])).filter((name) =>
/^playwright(?:\.[\w-]+)?\.config\.[cm]?[jt]s$/u.test(name),
);
const directories = await Promise.all(
configs.map(async (config) =>
/testDir:\s*["']\.?\/?([^"']+)["']/u.exec(await readFile(path.join(root, config), "utf8"))?.[1]
?.replace(/\/$/u, ""),
),
);
return directories.filter((directory): directory is string => directory !== undefined);
}
export type FeatureRoutes = Readonly<{
/** The removed feature's route paths. */
paths?: readonly string[];
/** Every route path left after the removal, platform routes included. */
remainingPaths?: readonly string[];
/** The removed feature's route IDs, platform IDs it took over left out. */
ids?: readonly string[];
}>;
export async function productFeatureResidue(
root: string,
featureId: string,
directory: string,
routePaths: readonly string[] = [],
routes: FeatureRoutes = {},
): Promise<string[]> {
const nameSet = new Set([featureId, directory]);
const names = [...nameSet].map(escapeRegExp).join("|");
const wholeAnyName = featureNamePattern(featureId, directory);
// A route ID left in platform source (a catalog key, `route.INVOICES_LIST`)
// is found by its whole name too.
const routeIds = [...new Set(routes.ids ?? [])].map(escapeRegExp);
const wholeRouteId =
routeIds.length === 0
? null
: new RegExp(`(?<![A-Za-z0-9_-])(?:${routeIds.join("|")})(?![A-Za-z0-9_-])`, "u");
const pathNames = (relativePath: string) =>
relativePath
.split("/")
@@ -111,20 +160,38 @@ export async function productFeatureResidue(
specNames.length === 0
? null
: new RegExp(`(?<![A-Za-z0-9_-])(?:${specNames.join("|")})(?![A-Za-z0-9_-])`, "u");
const prefixes = [
...new Set(routePaths.map(staticRoutePrefix).filter((prefix): prefix is string => prefix !== null)),
].map(escapeRegExp);
const routeString =
prefixes.length === 0
? null
: new RegExp(`["'\`](?:${prefixes.join("|")})(?=["'\`/?#])`, "u");
// A URL opens the route whose fixed prefix is the longest that fits it, so
// a sibling feature's `/invoices/lines` in the same context is not the
// removed `/invoices`. When a route left behind has the same prefix
// (`/invoices` beside a removed `/invoices/:id`), the URL is not counted.
const removed = prefixesOf(routes.paths ?? []);
const remaining = prefixesOf(routes.remainingPaths ?? []);
const candidates = [...new Set([...removed, ...remaining])].sort((a, b) => b.length - a.length);
const opensRemovedRoute = (text: string) => {
if (removed.size === 0) return false;
for (const match of text.matchAll(/["'`](\/[^"'`\s]*)/gu)) {
const best = candidates.find((prefix) => opens(match[1]!, prefix));
if (best !== undefined && removed.has(best) && !remaining.has(best)) return true;
}
return false;
};
const browserDirectories = await browserTestDirectories(root);
const playwrightSpec = /\.spec\.[cm]?[jt]sx?$/u;
// A page object or helper beside the specs (`tests/e2e/support/*.ts`) runs
// only in a browser too; a vitest test (`*.test.*`) does not.
const browserFile = (name: string) =>
playwrightSpec.test(name) ||
(!/\.test\.[cm]?[jt]sx?$/u.test(name) &&
browserDirectories.some((directory) => name.startsWith(`${directory}/`)));
const residue: string[] = [];
const relative = (file: string) => path.relative(root, file).split(path.sep).join("/");
for (const file of await filesUnder(path.join(root, "src"))) {
const name = relative(file);
if (name.startsWith("src/.generated/")) continue;
if (pathNames(name) || wholeAnyName.test(await readFile(file, "utf8"))) residue.push(name);
const text = await readFile(file, "utf8");
if (pathNames(name) || wholeAnyName.test(text) || (wholeRouteId !== null && wholeRouteId.test(text))) {
residue.push(name);
}
}
for (const file of await filesUnder(path.join(root, "tests"))) {
const name = relative(file);
@@ -132,9 +199,8 @@ export async function productFeatureResidue(
if (
pathNames(name) ||
imported.test(text) ||
(playwrightSpec.test(name) &&
((wholeName !== null && wholeName.test(text)) ||
(routeString !== null && routeString.test(text))))
(playwrightSpec.test(name) && wholeName !== null && wholeName.test(text)) ||
(browserFile(name) && opensRemovedRoute(text))
) {
residue.push(name);
}
+15 -8
View File
@@ -14,7 +14,7 @@ import { PLATFORM_ROUTE_REGISTRY } from "../src/contracts/routes.ts";
import { ROUTE_FEATURE_OWNER, routePath } from "../src/features/installed-feature-contracts.ts";
import { loadCiGateContract } from "./contracts/ci-gates.ts";
import { createFileSystemDeclarationSource } from "./generate-product-feature-index.ts";
import { featureNamePattern, productFeatureResidue } from "./lib/feature-residue.ts";
import { featureNamePattern, type FeatureRoutes, productFeatureResidue } from "./lib/feature-residue.ts";
import { isProductionModulePath } from "./lib/risk-coverage.ts";
import {
createRemovalFixtureRoot,
@@ -164,15 +164,22 @@ const located = await locateFeature(featureId);
const featureRouteIds = Object.entries(ROUTE_FEATURE_OWNER)
.filter(([, owner]) => owner === featureId)
.map(([routeId]) => routeId);
// 0925 FOLLOW-UP 09-07. A spec that opens the feature by one of these paths is
// residue (scripts/lib/feature-residue.ts). A platform path the feature took
// over (its home) goes back to the platform with the removal.
// 0925 FOLLOW-UP 09-07. A browser test that opens the feature by one of these
// paths is residue (scripts/lib/feature-residue.ts). A platform route the
// feature took over (its home) goes back to the platform with the removal.
const platformRoutePaths = new Set<string>(
Object.values(PLATFORM_ROUTE_REGISTRY).map((route) => route.path),
);
const featureRoutePaths = featureRouteIds
.map(routePath)
.filter((candidate) => !platformRoutePaths.has(candidate));
const featureRoutes: FeatureRoutes = Object.freeze({
paths: featureRouteIds.map(routePath).filter((candidate) => !platformRoutePaths.has(candidate)),
remainingPaths: [
...platformRoutePaths,
...Object.keys(ROUTE_FEATURE_OWNER)
.filter((routeId) => !featureRouteIds.includes(routeId))
.map(routePath),
],
ids: featureRouteIds.filter((routeId) => !Object.hasOwn(PLATFORM_ROUTE_REGISTRY, routeId)),
});
const fixtureRoot = await createRemovalFixtureRoot(`${featureId}-removal`);
const pnpmCli = requireRemovalFixtureEnvironment("npm_execpath");
@@ -470,7 +477,7 @@ try {
fixtureRoot,
featureId,
located.directory,
featureRoutePaths,
featureRoutes,
);
// 1105/16-04. The same whole-name rule as `src`: the template's bundle
// holds `data-product-feature`, which a substring search counted.
+73 -9
View File
@@ -99,31 +99,95 @@ describe("product feature residue (1105/16-04)", () => {
"tests/unit/route.test.ts": 'const target = "/invoice";\n',
});
expect(await productFeatureResidue(root, ID, ID, ["/invoice", "/invoice/:invoiceId"])).toEqual([
expect(await productFeatureResidue(root, ID, ID, { paths: ["/invoice", "/invoice/:invoiceId"] })).toEqual([
"tests/e2e/detail.spec.ts",
"tests/e2e/route-only.spec.ts",
"tests/visual/hash.visual.spec.ts",
]);
});
// Diff review of 09-07. The first feature of a context takes the context's
// path (`/invoice`) and a later one a path under it (`/invoice/line`), and
// the context stays while another feature is in it.
it("leaves a URL to a route still there with a longer prefix, such as a sibling feature's", async () => {
const root = await fixture({
"tests/e2e/lines.spec.ts": 'await page.goto("/invoice/line");\nawait page.goto("/invoice/line/7");\n',
"tests/e2e/detail.spec.ts": 'await page.goto("/invoice/7");\n',
"tests/e2e/shared-prefix.spec.ts": 'await page.goto("/report/2026");\n',
});
expect(
await productFeatureResidue(root, ID, ID, {
paths: ["/invoice", "/report/:year"],
remainingPaths: ["/", "/invoice/line", "/report"],
}),
).toEqual(["tests/e2e/detail.spec.ts"]);
});
it("stops a route prefix at an optional segment and finds a URL built with a template", async () => {
const root = await fixture({
"tests/e2e/edit.spec.ts": 'await page.goto("/invoice/edit");\n',
"tests/e2e/query.spec.ts": "await page.goto(`/invoice${query}`);\n",
});
expect(await productFeatureResidue(root, ID, ID, { paths: ["/invoice/edit?"] })).toEqual([
"tests/e2e/edit.spec.ts",
"tests/e2e/query.spec.ts",
]);
});
it("searches a page object in a Playwright testDir, not a mock or a vitest test", async () => {
const root = await fixture({
"playwright.config.ts": 'export default defineConfig({ testDir: "./tests/e2e" });\n',
"tests/e2e/support/invoice-page.ts": 'export const open = (page) => page.goto("/invoice");\n',
"tests/e2e/support/route.test.ts": 'const target = "/invoice";\n',
"tests/mocks/handlers/routes.ts": 'export const PAGE = "/invoice";\n',
});
expect(await productFeatureResidue(root, ID, ID, { paths: ["/invoice"] })).toEqual([
"tests/e2e/support/invoice-page.ts",
]);
});
it("finds the feature's route IDs in source by their whole name", async () => {
const root = await fixture({
"src/contracts/titles.ts": "export const TITLE = messages.route.INVOICE_LIST.title;\n",
"src/contracts/longer.ts": 'export const KEY = "INVOICE_LIST_V2";\n',
});
expect(await productFeatureResidue(root, ID, ID, { ids: ["INVOICE_LIST"] })).toEqual([
"src/contracts/titles.ts",
]);
});
it("does not search a route path that is the root before its first parameter", async () => {
const root = await fixture({
"tests/e2e/home.spec.ts": 'await page.goto("/");\nawait page.goto("/?lang=ko");\n',
});
expect(await productFeatureResidue(root, ID, ID, ["/", "/:invoiceId", "*"])).toEqual([]);
expect(await productFeatureResidue(root, ID, ID, { paths: ["/", "/:invoiceId", "*"] })).toEqual([]);
});
it("does not count the template's own specs for the route paths of a generated feature", async () => {
const specs: Record<string, string> = {};
for (const entry of await readdir("tests", { recursive: true })) {
const file = path.join("tests", entry).split(path.sep).join("/");
if (/\.spec\.[cm]?[jt]sx?$/u.test(file)) specs[file] = await readFile(file, "utf8");
it("does not count the template's own browser tests for the route paths of a generated feature", async () => {
const files: Record<string, string> = {};
for (const entry of await readdir(".")) {
if (/^playwright.*\.config\.ts$/u.test(entry)) files[entry] = await readFile(entry, "utf8");
}
const root = await fixture(specs);
expect(Object.keys(files)).toContain("playwright.config.ts");
for (const entry of await readdir("tests", { recursive: true, withFileTypes: true })) {
if (!entry.isFile()) continue;
const file = path.join(entry.parentPath, entry.name).split(path.sep).join("/");
if (!/\.[cm]?[jt]sx?$/u.test(file)) continue;
if (/^tests\/(?:e2e|visual|storybook|browser-capabilities)\//u.test(file) || /\.spec\./u.test(file)) {
files[file] = await readFile(file, "utf8");
}
}
const root = await fixture(files);
// create:feature product-feature declares PRODUCT_LIST at /product.
expect(await productFeatureResidue(root, "product-feature", "product-feature", ["/product"])).toEqual([]);
expect(
await productFeatureResidue(root, "product-feature", "product-feature", { paths: ["/product"] }),
).toEqual([]);
});
it("does not count a spec whose longer names only contain the ID", async () => {