fix(features)!: 기능이 아닌 폴더 표시를 NOT_A_FEATURE로 바꾸고 선언과 함께 두면 실패한다 (1103/09-09)

문제
src/features/<dir>/NOT_INSTALLED 표시는 "기능이 아닌 샘플 폴더"라는 뜻인데,
같은 단어가 런타임 상태 "선언됐지만 빌드·FEATURE_OVERRIDES가 뺀 기능"으로도
쓰였다(product-features.ts). 생성기는 feature-module.ts를 못 읽을 때만 표시를
찾았으므로, 샘플을 졸업시키며 표시를 지우지 않으면 표시가 "설치 안 됨"이라고
말하는 채로 조용히 설치됐다.

고른 방법
- 표시 이름을 NOT_A_FEATURE로 바꾼다(local-draft-feature 파일 이름 변경).
  런타임 상태 NOT_INSTALLED는 그대로 둔다.
- 생성기가 표시와 feature-module.ts가 함께 있으면 둘 중 무엇을 지울지 적고
  실패한다.
- 옛 이름 표시는 받지 않는다. 받으면 같은 다의가 남는다. 옛 표시만 있는
  폴더는 "has no feature-module.ts; … mark the directory with NOT_A_FEATURE"로
  실패해 새 이름을 알려 준다.
README 상태 표, starter-experience, 매뉴얼 errors·patterns 표를 맞췄다.

위험·한계
다운스트림이 자기 폴더에 NOT_INSTALLED 표시를 두었다면 생성 단계가 실패한다.
파일 이름만 바꾸면 된다.

검증
- RED: 생성기 테스트 3건(새 이름 허용, 옛 이름 거절, 동시 존재 거절)이
  수정 전 실패.
- generate-product-feature-index.test.ts 17건 통과. generate:feature-index
  통과. verify:documentation PASS_SCOPED. eslint, tsc(node·test) 통과.

BREAKING CHANGE: src/features/<dir>/NOT_INSTALLED 표시 파일은 더 이상
인식되지 않는다. 같은 자리에 NOT_A_FEATURE라는 이름으로 옮긴다.

Refs: docs/reviews/2026-11-03-maturity-review/09-app-core.md 09-09
This commit is contained in:
DongHyeonka
2026-11-04 20:19:17 +09:00
parent 851fdedbcd
commit 9edc8307b0
7 changed files with 60 additions and 16 deletions
+1 -1
View File
@@ -121,7 +121,7 @@ and
| `COMPOSED` | capability ledger, design documents | wired into the default production path | Default |
| `INSTALLED` | a project's own recipe catalog (step 10 of the recipe procedure) | the project added the recipe | Default, for that project |
| `RECIPE_AVAILABLE` | recipe catalog `status` | a recipe exists to copy; nothing is installed | Optional |
| `NOT_INSTALLED` | recipe catalog `defaultStatus`; a `src/features/<id>/NOT_INSTALLED` marker file | not part of the build | Optional (recipe) or Experimental (feature) |
| `NOT_INSTALLED` | recipe catalog `defaultStatus`; a declared feature the build or `FEATURE_OVERRIDES` left out. A sample directory that is no feature at all carries a `src/features/<dir>/NOT_A_FEATURE` marker file instead | not part of the build | Optional (recipe) or Experimental (feature) |
| `AVAILABLE_NOT_COMPOSED` | capability ledger; recipe `referenceRuntime.status` | code and tests exist; the default build leaves it out | Optional |
| `DESIGNED_NOT_IMPLEMENTED` | capability ledger, design documents | design approved, runtime missing | Experimental |
| `NOT_SELECTED` | capability ledger, design documents | deliberately not chosen | Not supported |
+2 -2
View File
@@ -115,8 +115,8 @@ selected app. Every build and check script runs it first; run it yourself with
`corepack pnpm generate:feature-index`. It fails, naming the file, when:
- a directory under `src/features/` has no `feature-module.ts` and no
`NOT_INSTALLED` marker file (`src/features/local-draft-feature/NOT_INSTALLED`
is the one intentional example);
`NOT_A_FEATURE` marker file (`src/features/local-draft-feature/NOT_A_FEATURE`
is the one intentional example), or has both;
- a feature names an undeclared context, or a context an undeclared app;
- a context or app exceeds its declared budget;
- `VITE_PRODUCT_FEATURES` names a feature the app does not declare. The
+2 -1
View File
@@ -55,7 +55,8 @@ lint / check:architecture / check:i18n → FE-GATE-002, FE-GATE-010
| `Context <context> belongs to undeclared app <app>` | `CONTEXT_APP_ID` 오타 | `src/contexts/<context>/context-module.ts` |
| `<file> must export a literal <NAME>` | 헤더를 상수 참조나 식으로 썼다. 생성기는 글자로 읽는다 | 그 파일. `export const <NAME> = "<값>";` 꼴 |
| `<file> must export a positive integer <NAME>` | 예산 값이 정수 리터럴이 아니다 | 그 파일 |
| `src/features/<dir> has no feature-module.ts; add one or mark the directory with NOT_INSTALLED` | 기능 폴더에 선언 파일이 없다 | `feature-module.ts`를 만들거나 `NOT_INSTALLED` 파일을 둔다 |
| `src/features/<dir> has no feature-module.ts; add one or mark the directory with NOT_A_FEATURE` | 기능 폴더에 선언 파일이 없다 | `feature-module.ts`를 만들거나, 기능이 아닌 샘플 폴더면 `NOT_A_FEATURE` 파일을 둔다 |
| `src/features/<dir> has both feature-module.ts and NOT_A_FEATURE; …` | 기능이 아니라고 표시한 폴더에 선언 파일이 있다 | 기능으로 설치하려면 `NOT_A_FEATURE`를 지운다. 설치하지 않으려면 `feature-module.ts`를 지운다 |
| `Duplicate generated feature ids: <id>` | 두 폴더가 같은 `FEATURE_MODULE_ID` | 한쪽 `feature-module.ts` |
| `Duplicate context id: <id>` | 두 폴더가 같은 `CONTEXT_MODULE_ID` | 한쪽 `context-module.ts` |
| `Context <context> feature cardinality <n> exceeds budget <max>` | context의 기능 수가 예산을 넘었다 | `CONTEXT_MAX_FEATURES`, 또는 새 context |
+1 -1
View File
@@ -99,7 +99,7 @@ const search = (q: string) =>
| 수정·삭제 명령 | 같은 V3 계약 (`PUT`, `PATCH`, `DELETE`) | 없음 (참조 기능은 생성 명령만 있다) | — |
| 낙관적 갱신 | `useApplicationMutation`의 `optimistic` 옵션 (`application-query.ts`) | 없음 | 런타임 테스트만 |
| 페이지 넘김 | `src/adapters/query-cache/index.ts`의 `createCursorPaginationRuntime` | 없음 (참조 기능은 커서 필터만, 다음 커서 없음) | 런타임 테스트만 |
| 로컬 저장(IndexedDB) | `recipes/frontend-capabilities/indexeddb-feature-capability.ts` + `product-composition.ts` | `src/features/local-draft-feature/` (`NOT_INSTALLED`, 설치되지 않음) | 계약 테스트 |
| 로컬 저장(IndexedDB) | `recipes/frontend-capabilities/indexeddb-feature-capability.ts` + `product-composition.ts` | `src/features/local-draft-feature/` (`NOT_A_FEATURE`, 기능이 아닌 샘플) | 계약 테스트 |
## 화면
+25 -9
View File
@@ -271,11 +271,17 @@ function requiredInteger(source: string, name: string, file: string): number {
}
/**
* 09-07 (D-10). A feature directory must declare itself or say it is not
* installed. A missing or misspelt `feature-module.ts` used to drop the
* 09-07 (D-10). A feature directory must declare itself or say it is not a
* feature. A missing or misspelt `feature-module.ts` used to drop the
* feature from the product without a word.
*
* 1103/09-09. The marker was named `NOT_INSTALLED`, the runtime state of a
* declared feature the build or the runtime document left out
* (`src/contracts/product-features.ts`). It marks something else, a directory
* that is no feature at all (an architecture sample), so it has its own name,
* and a directory may not carry both the marker and a declaration.
*/
export const NOT_INSTALLED_MARKER = "NOT_INSTALLED";
export const NOT_A_FEATURE_MARKER = "NOT_A_FEATURE";
async function readDeclarations(
directory: string,
@@ -292,17 +298,27 @@ async function readDeclarations(
for (const item of items) {
if (!item.isDirectory()) continue;
const file = resolve(directory, item.name, fileName);
const marker =
requiredUnless !== undefined &&
(await readFile(resolve(directory, item.name, requiredUnless)).then(
() => true,
() => false,
));
let source: string;
try {
found.push({ directory: item.name, file, source: await readFile(file, "utf8") });
source = await readFile(file, "utf8");
} catch {
if (requiredUnless === undefined) continue;
const marker = await readFile(resolve(directory, item.name, requiredUnless))
.then(() => true, () => false);
if (marker) continue;
if (requiredUnless === undefined || marker) continue;
throw new Error(
`src/features/${item.name} has no ${fileName}; add one or mark the directory with ${requiredUnless}`,
);
}
if (marker) {
throw new Error(
`src/features/${item.name} has both ${fileName} and ${requiredUnless}; delete ${requiredUnless} to install it, or ${fileName} to keep it out`,
);
}
found.push({ directory: item.name, file, source });
}
return found;
}
@@ -351,7 +367,7 @@ export async function createFileSystemDeclarationSource(
for (const declaration of await readDeclarations(
resolve(root, "src/features"),
"feature-module.ts",
NOT_INSTALLED_MARKER,
NOT_A_FEATURE_MARKER,
)) {
const feature: FeatureDeclaration = {
id: requiredLiteral(declaration.source, "FEATURE_MODULE_ID", declaration.file),
@@ -145,7 +145,7 @@ describe("app-scoped selection from ownership declarations", () => {
await expect(generateAppIndexes(overContexts, "a")).rejects.toThrow(/App a context cardinality 2 exceeds budget 1/);
});
it("refuses a feature directory without a declaration or NOT_INSTALLED marker (09-07)", async () => {
it("refuses a feature directory without a declaration or NOT_A_FEATURE marker (09-07)", async () => {
const files = {
"src/apps/a/app-module.ts": app("a"),
"src/contexts/c/context-module.ts": context("c", "a"),
@@ -158,12 +158,39 @@ describe("app-scoped selection from ownership declarations", () => {
);
const marked = await repo({
...files,
"src/features/typo/NOT_INSTALLED": "Composed only by tests.\n",
"src/features/typo/NOT_A_FEATURE": "Composed only by tests.\n",
});
const selected = await generateAppIndexes(marked, "a");
expect(selected.entries.map((entry) => entry.id)).toEqual(["f"]);
});
it("no longer accepts the old NOT_INSTALLED marker name (1103/09-09)", async () => {
// The word is the runtime state "declared but not selected"; a marker
// under that name is read as a missing declaration, naming the new one.
const root = await repo({
"src/apps/a/app-module.ts": app("a"),
"src/contexts/c/context-module.ts": context("c", "a"),
"src/features/sample/NOT_INSTALLED": "Composed only by tests.\n",
});
await expect(generateAppIndexes(root, "a")).rejects.toThrow(
/src\/features\/sample has no feature-module\.ts; add one or mark the directory with NOT_A_FEATURE/u,
);
});
it("refuses a marked directory that also declares a feature (1103/09-09)", async () => {
// Graduating a sample means deleting the marker; keeping both used to
// install the feature silently while the marker said it was none.
const root = await repo({
"src/apps/a/app-module.ts": app("a"),
"src/contexts/c/context-module.ts": context("c", "a"),
"src/features/f/feature-module.ts": feature("f", "c"),
"src/features/f/NOT_A_FEATURE": "Composed only by tests.\n",
});
await expect(generateAppIndexes(root, "a")).rejects.toThrow(
/src\/features\/f has both feature-module\.ts and NOT_A_FEATURE; delete NOT_A_FEATURE to install it, or feature-module\.ts to keep it out/u,
);
});
it("skips contexts without features and never imports another app's features", async () => {
const root = await repo({
"src/apps/a/app-module.ts": app("a"),